Project Case Study:10TA Cooling Tower Pump Support
Key Project Details
Location: Margam ‘A’ Power Plant
Project: Redesign of 10TA Cooling Tower Pump Support Framework
Date: 2019 – 2020
Engineer: Ingleside Engineering Ltd
Project Background
The 10TA cooling tower pumps, part of the Margam ‘A’ Power Plant cooling system, were found to experience severe vibration and resonance. This caused operational issues, structural fatigue, and risk to connected pipework. Ingleside Engineering was engaged to develop a permanent solution to eliminate the resonance and allow reliable operation.
Key Challenges
- Pump frame entered resonance at operational speed.
- Simply supported steel beams lacked stiffness, amplifying vibration.
- Frame and pump base were out of level by up to 11 mm.
- Dynamic loads transmitted into the sump and pipework.
- Previous modifications failed to control vibration.
Key Challenges
- Conducted on-site vibration and level surveys with Tata engineers.
- Reviewed AMS Amplification Survey and design data.
- Compared against successful installations at adjacent locations.
- Identified the need to raise the structure’s natural frequency above the pump’s operating range.
Key Challenges
- Replaced 305×165×46 UB sections with 305×305×97 UC members to increase stiffness and reduce deflection fivefold.
- Converted structure from simply supported to fixed-end beam design.
- Integrated saddle supports into the new frame, removing reliance on wall brackets.
- Upgraded bedplate thickness from 4 mm to 12 mm.
- Installed TICO vibration isolation pads and flexible pipe bellows.
- Added restraint brackets and trestle supports in line with Tata recommendations.
- Verified alignment and installation against manufacturer tolerances.
Key Challenges
- Issued full fabrication and installation drawings (IEL-C186-001 to 007).
- Sequenced works to maintain operational safety and access.
- Collaborated with Civil & Structural Consultants (F2556) for foundation checks.
- Monitored vibration performance post-installation to validate improvements.
Key Challenges
- Resonance eliminated within pump operating speeds.
- Vibration reduced to within safe operational limits.
- Improved reliability and longevity of both pumps and structure.
- Reduced maintenance frequency and unplanned downtime.
- Delivered safely and efficiently, meeting Tata Steel design standards.
Key Results
Objectives
- RReduce vibration and resonance
- RImprove structural stiffness
- RExtend equipment lifespan
- REnsure reliable operation
Results
- AAchieved - resonance eliminated
- A5 times increase in stiffness at UC design
- AReduced fatigue and deflection
- APumps operating smoothly and safely
